Skip to content

Carrier Management

Critical Information for P/C Carrier Executives

Highlights

  • Help Me Understand: How Insurers Build Trust
  • Exclude It, Harness It, Get Greedy: Insurers' AI Playbook
  • Ranking Industry AI Talent, Maturity Leaders
  • Carrier Management
  • C-Suite
  • News
  • Research
  • Leadership
  • Markets
  • Regulation
  • Top 50
  • Members Only
  • Join
  • Login
  • Boardroom Agenda
  • CEO / Chief Executive
  • CFO / Financial
  • Underwriting
  • CTO / Technology
  • Risk
  • Brand Management & Sales
  • Investment Officers
  • Claims / Legal
  • Talent Management
How to Manage Stress and Practice Gratitude This Thanksgiving
How Is AI Being Used in Insurance Recruiting?
  • U.S.
  • International
  • Industry News
  • Government
  • Technology & Science
Number of Americans Traveling Over Thanksgiving Holiday Expected to Dip Slightly
Grand Theft Auto VI Frenzy Highlights Digital Infrastructure Insurance Risks

See all News

  • Executive Spotlight
  • Innovation
  • Strategy
  • Leadership
  • Performance
  • Growth Initiatives
  • Social Responsibility
Captives Weren’t a Hard Market Moment; They’re a Permanent Shift
Multimodal Claims Intake with Agentic AI: A Practical Architecture
  • Reinsurance
  • Emerging Markets
  • Global Economy
  • Personal Lines
  • Commercial Lines
  • Specialty
Insurance Loss Estimates for Microsoft Outage Range From $100M to $700M: Reports
Allstate’s AI Ecosystem to Include a Personal Agentic Assistant for Customers
  • Insurance Regulation
  • Securities Regulation
  • Accounting & Tax
  • Rating Agencies
US P/C Insurers See Fewer Ratings Downgrades in H1 2026 on Improved Performance
Insurance Regulators Defend State-Led Model in Reply to Warren
Weather Service Confirms 2 Tornadoes Touched Down in Arizona Last Week
Rhode Island Man Involved in $5M Vehicle Theft Ring Pleads Guilty
Human Error, Systemic Failure Blamed for Spain’s Latest Deadly Train Crash
Insurance AI’s Next Test: Can Carriers Trust the Data?

See all Top 50

How AI Tracks Digital Footprints to Uncover Fraud
INSTANDA CEO Sees Governance, Human Oversight As Top AI Priorities
Thinking Past the Patch in Managing Tech Debt
Policy Disconnects, Deferred Mitigation Escalate Weather-Related Claims

See all Members Only Content

Benefits

  • News for the P/C Insurance C-Suite - Focused reporting from reliable sources and experienced financial journalists.
  • Research and Analysis Not Found Elsewhere - Exclusive content from researchers think tanks, industry experts and respected analysts.
  • High-Profile Peers - Interviews with thought leaders in the global and U.S. insurance industry.

Online Access

Complete, unrestricted access to the popular CarrierManagement.com website, which provides insurance company C-suite executives with daily news, white papers, advice, instruction and editorial on how to manage insurance companies more efficiently and more effectively.

Viewpoint: Why Activists Should Rethink Hard Insurance Exits From Fossil Fuel Underwriting

Print Email
June 20, 2023 by David Sampson

Insurers play an important role in helping protect families, businesses and communities as our economy transitions to a greener energy future. However, those protections are coming under increased pressure from activists demanding an immediate cessation of insurance services for certain fossil fuel activities.

The call for an immediate end to insurance services for certain fossil fuel activities and producers ignores the importance of providing an effective energy transition to renewable sources. The 2022 Economic Report of the President recognized that transitioning the United States to clean energy even by mid-century would require an unprecedented transformation. President Biden also said that trying to move to renewable energy overnight “is just not rational.”

Energy expert Daniel Yergin underscores the need for an appropriate energy transition in his book “The New Map” and emphasizes that the nature and scope of that transition period differs from one nation to another. Equally important, many fossil fuel companies have the most technological expertise in the quest for reliable, renewable energy, so cutting off access to important financial services like insurance may actually slow the progress of a transition to renewable energy.

Limiting insurance coverage won’t stop most fossil fuel production, but it may unfortunately increase the risk of environmental disasters when safety, loss control, risk identification and mitigation controls facilitated by the insurance underwriting process are removed. Indeed, immediate cessation of insurance for certain fossil fuel activities and companies could rightly be viewed as anti-environmental.

Insurance carriers provide unique insights into risk mitigation and prevention in carbon intensive industries. For example, insurers empower well operators to implement prevention standards and monitor blowout performances, helping to significantly reduce environmental risk. This is a positive contribution that should be widely encouraged.

“Insurers are now facing more than a hundred ESG proposals…There is a seemingly endless parade of pro- and anti-ESG dictates where insurance is being weaponized to try to force policy outcomes that should be decided by legislatures.”

The property/casualty insurance industry protects the framework of U.S. commerce and innovation. And yet, our industry currently finds itself being pushed and pulled in conflicting directions because of the contentious public debate about corporate engagement on ESG issues.

For example, Connecticut made an attempt to penalize companies that underwrite fossil fuel interests. New York and California attempted to impose stricter emissions disclosures. Some environmental coalitions (such as Insuring Our Future) have even called on insurers to boycott fossil fuel production. Meanwhile, Texas and West Virginia prohibit their states from doing business with firms that agree to such boycotts and have proposed to prohibit such “economic discrimination.”

Insurers are now facing more than a hundred ESG proposals trying to dictate how financial firms engage on everything from energy production, guns, vaccinations, trade with China, abortion and biodiversity. There is a seemingly endless parade of pro- and anti-ESG dictates where insurance is being weaponized to try to force policy outcomes that should be decided by legislatures.

Both ends of the spectrum of the ESG debate are creating obstacles that may not only interfere with the effective regulation of insurers but also have serious unintended consequences that directly conflict with the underlying mission of the proponents. Regardless of one’s ideological stance on ESG matters, as a practical matter, if the targeted businesses are allowed to continue to legally operate, insurance plays an essential role in protecting the workers, consumers and surrounding society from potential harm. With respect to energy production, insurance both helps facilitate the transition to a lower-carbon society and ensure that energy development projects continue to operate in the safest manner possible.

Consumers, society and the environment ultimately benefit through greater availability and affordability of insurance when insurers have the flexibility to conduct business in line with widely accepted actuarial standards and are free to pursue different risk-based investing and underwriting strategies.

Print Email
Commercial LinesFeaturedRiskU.S.

Was this article valuable?

Thank you! Please tell us what we can do to improve this article.

Thank you! % of people found this article valuable. Please tell us what you liked about it.

Here are more articles you may enjoy.

Autonomy in Insurance: Defining the Industry’s Next Transformation
Multimodal Claims Intake with Agentic AI: A Practical Architecture
How AI Tracks Digital Footprints to Uncover Fraud
Road Deaths Declined to Historic Levels in First Half of 2026

Contributor

David Sampson, APCIA

David A. Sampson is President and CEO of the American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA).

Related Articles

Unsyncopated Clocks: ‘Fire and Flood’ Book Highlights Insurers’ Climate-Change Late Show

Our Contributors

Tim EyrePolicy Disconnects, Deferred Mitigation Escalate Weather-Related Claims
Christopher WoodingHow AI Tracks Digital Footprints to Uncover Fraud
Łukasz PietruchaQuality Engineering as the Foundation of Intelligent Insurance Systems
Terry BuechnerThinking Past the Patch in Managing Tech Debt
Srinivasan SeshadriAutonomy in Insurance: Defining the Industry’s Next Transformation
Shan GuruvadooErasing Unmodeled Marine Risk: A Strategic Framework for CUOs
See All Our Contributors

Free Newsletter

NewsletterSign up to receive daily news!

Our Contributors

Christopher WoodingHow AI Tracks Digital Footprints to Uncover FraudTerry BuechnerThinking Past the Patch in Managing Tech DebtTim EyrePolicy Disconnects, Deferred Mitigation Escalate Weather-Related ClaimsSrinivasan SeshadriAutonomy in Insurance: Defining the Industry’s Next TransformationSee All Our Contributors

Latest

  • How to Manage Stress and Practice Gratitude This Thanksgiving
  • Number of Americans Traveling Over Thanksgiving Holiday Expected to Dip Slightly
  • How Is AI Being Used in Insurance Recruiting?
  • Grand Theft Auto VI Frenzy Highlights Digital Infrastructure Insurance Risks
  • Professional Networking Is a Job Search Asset AI Can’t Replace
  • Captives Weren’t a Hard Market Moment; They’re a Permanent Shift
  • Florida Approves 7.4% Average Workers’ Comp Rate Cut for 2027
  • Despite Increasing Threat, Users Keep Same Password Combos
  • C-Suite
  • News
  • Leadership
  • Markets
  • Regulation
  • Top 50
  • Members Only
  • Videos

Headlines

  • Help Me Understand: How Insurers Build Trust
  • Exclude It, Harness It, Get Greedy: Insurers' AI Playbook
  • Ranking Industry AI Talent, Maturity Leaders

Resources

  • Videos / Podcasts
  • Contributors

Popular Topics

  • Boardroom Agenda
  • Technology
  • Financial
  • News

Partner Perspectives

  • Cotality
  • Cytora
  • HazardHub
  • Indico Data
  • Majesco
  • Origami Risk
  • Verisk
  • Vertafore

Connect with us

  • Email Newsletters
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Do Not Sell My Info

Carrier Management

  • Submit Content
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Contact Us

Wells Media Group Network

  • Carrier Management iconCarrier Management
  • Insurance Journal iconInsurance Journal
  • Claims Journal iconClaims Journal
  • IJ Academy iconInsurance Journal Academy
  • Insurance Journal TV iconInsurance Journal TV
  • MyNewMarkets.com iconMyNewMarkets.com
© 2026 by Wells Media Group, Inc. Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Site Map