While there was debate about the wisdom of the Tokyo Olympics proceeding as scheduled given the current health conditions, the insurance industry dodged a bullet with the go-ahead. According to Reuters, the Tokyo Olympics are insured for approximately $2 billion plus a further $600 million for the hospitality industry. Although fans will are not in attendance, which will impact the latter number, the events and television coverage are proceeding, saving the industry from significant fallout.
For festival attendees, music lovers, and sports fans, 2020 was a truly miserable year — almost all live events were canceled due to the pandemic. And now, as the world reopens, hopes for a “summer of fun” are being dashed again. The events sector is not only facing uncertainty about the pandemic, but a new hurdle: insurance.
Executive SummaryWhile the Tokyo Olympics has finally gone ahead, the ongoing coronavirus pandemic puts other large-scale events at risk. Because of that, the events sector is facing uncertainty about insurance as well as COVID-19, as insurers withdraw capacity, writes Guidewire Chief Innovation Officer Paul Mang.
Music fans were shocked when one of the world’s most iconic gatherings, the UK’s Glastonbury Festival, broke the news that its 2021 event would not take place. The reason? It was reportedly impossible to obtain appropriate event cancellation coverage at a reasonable cost.
In 2020, event cancellation was one of the insurance lines that were most affected by the pandemic. Market losses are still unknown and will depend on how the rest of 2021 plays out, but sources suggest that these losses are likely to run to several billion dollars.
Unsurprisingly, the event cancellation market is looking markedly different today. In the absence of government support, all coverage excludes pandemic cancellation, and obtaining wider cancellation coverage is also becoming tricky. A withdrawal of capacity means that prices — which were already high — are increasingly prohibitive for many potential policyholders.
The impact on the events industry could be huge. A survey by the Association of Independent Festivals in the UK found that 95.8 percent of independent festivals are not covered by insurance for COVID-19 cancellations. The largest music festival in the US, Coachella, recently canceled its 2021 event due to uncertainty relating to the pandemic, while other major events such as Lollapalooza are scheduled to take place in some cities (Chicago, for example) but not in others (the Paris event has been canceled).
The Tip of the Iceberg
The future of this market is potentially in doubt. Price and relevance are becoming major issues, and if insurers can’t provide the answer, we should make no mistake — other sources of capital will soon fill the gap.
There is also a broader issue at stake. The current situation demonstrates the importance of insurance to society and the wider economy. So much that we take for granted relies on an insurance backstop; when that disappears, the consequences are significant.
Event insurance may be a small market, but the wider insurance market has similar challenges. The world is facing ever more complex risks, many of which don’t fit neatly into insurers’ traditional business models — think cyber or reputational risk. If the insurance industry fails to find solutions, its very relevance in the modern economy will be called into question.
Today’s challenge in the events space is, therefore, just the tip of the iceberg of a much bigger problem. So, it’s vital that the industry be proactive in being part of the solution. There is no silver bullet. The industry must work creatively, engage with a range of stakeholders, and take advantage of the latest technologies if it judiciously commits capital to this space.
Evolving and Learning from a wave of Event Cancellations
So, what does a proactive response look like?
First, engagement with governments and local authorities will be key. Providing coverage for pandemic-related losses for large events will likely need a public/private solution. Angel Gurría, Secretary-General of the Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development (OECD), recently called on the insurance industry to be more proactive in making this viable.
“We urgently need the insurance sector’s support to develop tools and expertise that will help us better manage future pandemic risk, while reducing demands on government finances,” Gurría told a conference.
Reaching a solution will be complicated and take time, but the industry must ensure that it has a seat at the table so that the “private” element of the partnership works to efficiently leverage insurance balance sheets.
Second, investing in the latest agile technologies will help the industry prudently offer affordable and relevant solutions. In the post-pandemic world, insurers will require more granular scrutiny of policyholders as well as a sharper focus on aggregation risk, which until recently has received minimal attention in this space.
Achieving this at scale is possible thanks to remarkable advances in cloud technologies and predictive and risk modeling approaches that efficiently harvest relevant data. This combination is enabling our industry to achieve what we refer to as “continuous underwriting,” which provides a wealth of on-demand, detailed data in a matter of minutes and enables underwriters to track exposures throughout policy lifecycles.
The 2020 launch of COVID-related delay and cancellation coverage created for the TV and film industry by specialist MGA SpottedRisk is a good example of how a highly analytical approach can unlock innovation in a challenging market. It also serves as a warning to mainstream insurers about how quickly gaps in the market can be filled by more agile, less traditional players.
Although it’s necessary to bring more data and analytics to bear on complex risk problems, that should just be the start. As an industry, we must also enable the data to move efficiently throughout the insurance network if we want to deliver innovation and develop new value propositions.
What we might call “connected-insurance,” a term that refers to the need for improved data standards, increased data sharing, and better systems for enabling data to flow among entities. Today, insurers and brokers are investing in tracking and curating their own data and accessing external data. But the industry will need to develop a more connected platform so that creative solutions can be developed for vexing problems.
Whether or not events continue to be postponed or cancelled remains to be seen. What is clear is that the insurance market does have options for how it responds and takes this market forward.
As the world sees ever more complex risks, it’s essential that the industry find a way to respond positively. Today’s challenge in the event-cancellation space is just one example of how this may play out, and it provides us with an opportunity to learn how to evolve our response as an industry and as individual companies.
Paul Mang is Chief Innovation Officer at Guidewire, a provider of predictive analytics, risk insights and business intelligence solutions for the P&C insurance industry. He is the former Global CEO of Analytics at Aon plc.