As Congress tries to figure out how to change the federal flood insurance program to encourage more private insurer involvement, one insurer isn’t waiting to wade deeper into the private flood insurance business. HCI Group is looking to take its Florida flood insurance experience and its proprietary flood insurance technology to nine additional states.
Florida-based HCI Group said it has begun the regulatory process to expand its private flood insurance operation into Arkansas, California, Maryland, North Carolina, New Jersey, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina and Texas.
Currently, the company offers flood insurance solely in Florida, where it has about 4,000 policies. It writes flood both as an endorsement to its standard homeowners policy in its established homeowners subsidiary, Homeowners Choice Property & Casualty Insurance Co., and as standalone coverage through its relatively new TypTap subsidiary, a proprietary InsurTech platform it created.
“A core part of our long-term strategic plan has been—and continues to be—expanding and diversifying our operations geographically. We believe expansion into additional markets will leverage our proven business model, as well as our internally developed technology,” said Paresh Patel, HCI Group’s chairman and chief executive officer.
Kevin Mitchell, HCI’s vice president for investor relations, said the company is just beginning to talk with state regulators to see what approach will work best in each state.
Unlike some other private offerings, HCI is targeting middle-market homes, not preferred or high-end properties. The middle-income residents on the water are the ones “who really need the help,” said Mitchell.
He told CM sister publication Insurance Journal that HCI will be expanding regardless of what Congress does to change the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). If Congress alters the rules of the program to encourage more private insurers to sell, that’s fine with HCI.
“Competition is healthy. We need the competition. We can’t write every risk,” Mitchell said.
While the insurer has been writing flood policies in Florida since 2013, HCI really ramped up its effort in April 2016. That was when HCI launched a separate flood-coverage-only company called TypTap to sell standalone flood policies in Florida using a proprietary online platform for quoting and binding flood policies.
HCI is betting on its technology to help it capture market share. “The technology is the big thing,” said Mitchell. “It really hit a chord with agents.”
The TypTap technology makes it easy for agents to sell and property owners to buy flood coverage. For potential customers, the process starts with them typing in their address. They only need to answer three questions and then pick an agent from a dropdown menu to finish the policy purchasing process.
The technology is important, but TypTap also competes with NFIP on coverage and pricing. TypTap offers replacement cost on contents, no 30-day waiting period and no elevation certificate. The coverage also offers a loss-of-use component, which isn’t available through NFIP policies, as well as up to $500,000 on the building limit and up to $250,000 on replacement and contents with underwriting approval.
According to Mitchell, TypTap can price its policies competitively because of its experience, its pricing models, and because it does not have the burden of past losses from Katrina, Sandy and other storms which NFIP must surcharge policyholders to cover. NFIP is about $24 billion in debt.
“You have to be competitive,” Mitchell said, noting that HCI is “coming in with a fresh look at the peril of flood” and isn’t paying for Katrina or Sandy. “You’re not trying to surcharge the customer to make up for underwriting mistakes.”
Mitchell said it’s “unfair” for new policyholders to have to pay for NFIP’s debt. “That’s not their fault,” he said.
But again, according to Mitchell, the technology is key. “You have to have the tech right to make it really work,” he said. “If we had a great flood product but everyone had to send in an ACORD form, it just wouldn’t work.”
He said that his company has not had any problem satisfying lending requirements with its policies because it is an admitted carrier. Policyholders and agents also appreciate the “long-term commitment” HCI has made to the flood market, he noted.
Florida accounts for 37 percent of the NFIP’s policies, and leaders in the state have complained that its homeowners pay into NFIP more than they get in return and pay disproportionately higher rates than the rest of the country.
HCI Group owns subsidiaries engaged in homeowners insurance, reinsurance, real estate and information technology services. The company’s largest subsidiary, Homeowners Choice Property & Casualty Insurance Co., is a leading provider of property/casualty insurance in Florida.