Free Preview

This is a preview of some of our exclusive, member only content. If you enjoy this article, please consider becoming a member.

A familiar debate is resurfacing across the industry: If parts of the commercial market begin to soften, will the organizations that moved into captives or other alternative structures over the past several years simply move back to the traditional markets?

Having worked closely with carriers, captive managers and risk leaders, I think the narrative around a captive market pullback misses the bigger picture. The data suggests that captives are no longer viewed as a temporary response to challenging insurance cycles. They are increasingly recognized as a strategic and permanent part of the risk-taking landscape. If anything, 2027 is likely to confirm the continued expansion and maturation of the captive market.

Why Captives Were Never Just a Hard Market Reaction

It’s true that today’s wave of captive growth has roots in hard-market pressure: tightening capacity, climbing rates on certain lines, and newer or fast-growing classes of business that the broader commercial market hasn’t fully caught up to yet. But treating that as the whole story misses what happens once an organization forms a captive.

Standing one up isn’t a quick fix. It requires governance, regulatory approval, capital commitment and real organizational investment. Once a company has done that work, and started taking on risk, building out risk management practices and getting more involved in the claims process, the captive becomes embedded in how that business operates. It stops being a side arrangement and becomes part of the core insurance value chain. That kind of structural commitment doesn’t unwind just because rates ease somewhere else in the market.

Why the Soft Market Exodus Didn’t Come

That’s also why the predicted retreat hasn’t materialized. Once participants are inside a captive, they see its upside: the ability to share in favorable underwriting results instead of leaving that margin entirely with a carrier, more control over claims handling and risk data, and a structure that rewards the loss-control work they’re already doing. Walking away from that, even in a softer cycle, means giving up ground that took real effort to gain including unrecognized prior-year underwriting profits.

The volume tells the story. Captive formations have continued climbing, and what strikes me most isn’t just the pace but who’s forming them now. For most of my career, captives were viewed as an alternative arrangement that few companies wanted to engage with, generally reserved for large, resource-rich organizations. That’s no longer the case. Smaller and midsize companies are accessing captive structures in ways that simply weren’t practical a decade ago, often with support from established captive managers who’ve built out robust onboarding and vetting processes for companies of varying sizes.

What This Shift Changes for Everyone in the Value Chain

That broader access is part of a bigger theme I’d describe as the outsourcing of the insurance value chain. Carriers are leaning on more outsourced tools for underwriting and distribution. Captives and third-party administrators are taking on more of the risk-bearing and claims management work. For carriers, that means competing in a market where a meaningful and growing share of risk sits outside the traditional model entirely—not temporarily but as a structural feature of the market going forward. For claims and TPA partners, it means deeper, longer-term relationships with captive owners who are more engaged in outcomes than a typical commercial insured. And for risk managers, it means more responsibility, and also more upside, than they’ve historically had.

Making Sure a Captive Is Ready to Be Used

None of this means captives are risk-free or right for every organization. A captive doesn’t have to accept every member or every risk, and it shouldn’t. Organizations considering one, whether forming a new captive or joining an existing one, should start with good data: actual losses, actual exposures, and how those compare to peer and industry benchmarks. Talking with peers who are already in a captive, or exploring one, is some of the most useful due diligence available, and established captive managers can offer onboarding and vetting support that shortens the learning curve considerably.

The single biggest failure point I’ve seen isn’t a bad risk or a bad year. It’s an unrealistic business plan: organizations that target too many members, too much premium or too much return too quickly and then come up short. That shortfall doesn’t just disappoint; it constrains the captive’s ability to operate the way it was designed to, straining relationships with partners along the way. The lesson is straightforward: build a plan that’s actionable and realistic, not aspirational. Overpromising and underdelivering create problems that are much harder to unwind than the ones a captive was meant to solve in the first place.

Looking Ahead to 2027

Heading into 2027, I expect this trajectory to continue rather than reverse, regardless of where the broader cycle moves next. One more piece worth watching is AI’s role in this space. I expect it to expand, but mainly as an efficiency and productivity tool, sharpening underwriting, claims and risk-management workflows. Captives remain, at their core, a people- and relationship-driven business built on educated decision-making. That’s not something AI is positioned to replace, nor should we expect it to.

The market tension playing out right now is real, but I’d frame it differently than a tug-of-war between the traditional and captive models. Captives have earned a permanent seat at the table. The organizations that benefit most in 2027 will be the ones treating that seat seriously, with good data, realistic plans and genuine investment in risk management, rather than those waiting to see which way the cycle breaks.