EU Fines Microsoft $731M

March 6, 2013 by Foo Yun Chee

The European Union fined Microsoft Corp 561 million euros ($731 million) on Wednesday for

failing to offer users a choice of web browser, an unprecedented sanction that will act as a warning to other firms involved in EU antitrust disputes.

It said the U.S. software company had broken a legally binding commitment made in 2009 to ensure that consumers had a choice of how they access the internet, rather than defaulting to Microsoft’s Explorer browser.

An investigation found that Microsoft had failed to honor that obligation in software issued between May 2011 and July 2012, meaning 15 million users were not given a choice.

It is the first time the European Commission, the EU’s antitrust authority, has handed down a fine to a company for failing to meet its obligations.

While the sanction is sizeable, representing more than 11 percent of Microsoft’s expected net profit this quarter and 1 percent of annual sales, the Commission could have charged the company up to 10 percent of annual global revenue.

“If companies agree to offer commitments which then become legally binding, they must do what they have committed to do or face the consequences,” Joaquin Almunia, the EU’s competition

commissioner, told a news conference. “I hope this decision will make companies think twice before

they even think of intentionally breaching their obligations or even of neglecting their duty to ensure strict compliance.”

Microsoft said it took full responsibility for the incident, which it has blamed on a technical error. The board cut chief executive Steve Ballmer’s bonus last year partly as a result, and also faulted former Windows head Steven Sinofsky who left the company last year for unrelated reasons.

The company did not say whether it would challenge the ruling, but it is not expected to do so, largely so as not to antagonize regulators.

“We have apologized for it,” Microsoft said in a statement. “We provided the Commission with a complete and candid assessment of the situation, and we have taken steps to strengthen our software development and other processes to help avoid this mistake—or anything similar—in the future.”

Almunia said regulators may have made a mistake by allowing Microsoft to police its own behavior instead of appointing an external trustee to ensure compliance with the commitments. “In 2009, we were even more naive than today,” he said.

Warning Shot To Google, Others

Microsoft’s fine is a good example of the Commission’s hard line approach towards companies which disregard rules whether deliberately or not, said Charles Whiddington, a partner atLondon-based law firm Field Fisher Waterhouse. “The implications for companies going forward is that they must be more rigorous in complying with any agreement with the Commission, which does not take prisoners for infractions,”he said.

“Companies face severe sanctions for flouting EU rules, even accidentally.”

Wednesday’s fine brings the total of EU fines issued against Microsoft over the past decade to more than 2.2 billion euros, making it the world’s worst offender of EU rules.

While the charge could have been higher, it still marks a firm sanction and will be carefully noted by the likes of Google, which is involved in a dispute with the Commission over how it ranks search engine results.

Google is under pressure to offer concessions to prevent the Commission moving to the next stage in the case, which could involve fines. Other major technology firms such as Samsung Electronics are also under investigation.

Wednesday’s decision is expected to help Microsoft draw a line under its troubles in Europe as it gears up for an intensified battle against Google. Microsoft is one of the complainants in the EU’s investigation into the search giant.

Almunia has also signaled EU regulators’ concern over antitrust issues in the links between technology platform owners and application developers, in a move that could spell trouble for Apple Inc. and Google, whose iPads and Android tablets are the leading the growth of the computer market.